About

I am currently studying for a PhD. I work mainly with Drosophila melanogaster, messing around with their DNA and RNA.

I started this blog mostly for my own benefit – an important part of being a scientist is being able to explain what you do to the lay public, and this is my way of practicing. I also agree with the idea that you only know if you really know something when you try and explain it to someone else. Doing this forces me to do background reading I may have tactically relegated to desk-levelling material.

My other motivation is I feel science has a hell of a lot to offer to everyone – what the word “science” covers is  absolutely vast , and a lot of it is really interesting. The majority,  however, is hidden from the majority. Behind lab doors in the hands of scientists that don’t just consider that an esoteric journal isn’t the only place to show their work. Depressingly often, what the public do get to see is the media-filtered, watered down version of science with emphasis on perceived or over-hyped controversies. They never get to see what a scientist does day to day, how they think, or why they think their bizarre area or freaky organism is so amazing.

What can I do about this? Obviously it’s limited – I didn’t graduate that long ago. But in the time since, I have amassed a library of images of my work, which in their own right are visually and scientifically interesting. Only a subset of this make it into reports or presentations I produce, and the audiences for this are exceptionally limited (no further than other academics). It seems to me that it is a huge waste to horde these pictures on a hard drive where no-one will ever see them.

My aim here is to show the images I have already, and any I produce in the future, related to my work and not, hopefully to impart upon others the sense of wonder I get looking at the world under a microscope.

Don’t let my name fool you into thinking I’m not a nice person, it is essentially (in my view) a parody. Some scientists may sound arrogant, but the world of science-arguments is very different to “pop-arguments”. Scientists tend to be objective – they don’t tend to make personal arguments, and even relish the chance to have their ideas contested by others. Generally, they don’t wade into arguments when they don’t know what they’re talking about, preferring ones where they can speak with confidence.

I do have some strong personal views on what are non-controversial issues in science, but are politically charged in real life. For example, religion, evolution, the paranormal and the thing I hate the most – faith. As a scientist I never have “faith” in anything – I have the best view I can based on the available evidence, but never faith that something is correct or present without evidence. And then I will test that view, no matter who’s opinions it goes against, even my own. Essentially, I believe (with the weight of the whole of science behind me) that a scientific philosophy is the only really fulfilling way to live, and understand, your life.

head1

A note on my pictures and articles – please do not reproduce these anywhere else without my explicit permission, which I will likely give if asked. Please respect the fact I have put time and effort into producing them. All the pictures are my work, unless otherwise stated.

Contact: arrogantscientist@googlemail.com

Responses

  1. Hello,

    My name is Josh. You posted a comment on my thesis the other day.

    I greatly appreciate your desire to share your research with the masses; I heartily agree with your assertion that, “you only know if you really know something when you try and explain it to someone else.” Sadly, science has become so specialized and compartmentalized that lay persons—as even scientists from different fields—do not reap the benefits of the vast majority of work done in labs.

    I also appreciate your statements about faith. You made the comment that you would never hold to a blind faith or, “[faith] that something is correct or present without evidence.” This type of “blind faith” is both foolish and dangerous. As a Christian, I am often dismayed when other Christians speak about blind faith—as if this were the type of faith the Bible teaches us to have.

    I appreciate that you took the time to read my paper; however, I wish you could give me better feedback. It’s obvious to me that you disagree with my thesis and find my arguments weak. If you have the time, I would love for you to elaborate on this.

    Thanks again for your comment and keep up the good work in the lab!

    Most Sincerely,

    J. Matthan Brown

  2. Dear “Arrogant” Scientist,

    Thanks for your explanation on balancer chromosomes.

    In addition, I feel there is a certain inconsistency in the paragraph below:

    “and the thing I hate the most – FAITH. As a scientist I never have “FAITH” in anything – I have the best view I can based on the available evidence, but never faith that something is correct or present without evidence. And then I will test that view, no matter who’s opinions it goes against, even my own. Essentially, I BELIEVE (with the WEIGHT OF THE WHOLE OF SCIENCE BEHIND ME) that a scientific philosophy is the only really fulfilling way to live, and understand, your life.” (emphasis added)

    I am not a native English speaker (I am Hungarian) but I feel that if you believe something about scientific philosophy (i.e. that it is the only really fulfilling way to live etc.), it is a kind of faith. Not the mention that in the “whole science” you respect a world of opinions only assumed (by you) to be correct.

    I am interested in your opinion, of course.

    Kind regards,

    Adam

  3. Hi Adam,

    You raise a good point about the meaning of “belief” and “faith”. The problem with them is they are pretty much synonyms. You could use either one in a sentence and it would not change the meaning of the sentence.

    However, above I have used them to mean different things, and perhaps I should have been clearer, as they can mean different things to different people, as well as meaning exactly the same thing to other people.

    When I say belief, I mean any idea held by someone, without judging the quality of the idea. For example, the idea that the world is round and the idea that the world is flat are both beliefs.

    I consider faith as a subset of belief, defined as an unreasonable belief. I.e. believe without evidence, or despite the evidence. For example, I would consider someone’s belief that the earth is flat as faith.

    As for “faith” in science, I do have faith in science, because I cannot possibly verify all results in every discipline myself. I have to trust that other scientists are doing proper science, which is not always the case. However, I know that the philosophy of science works. It is objective and the results are reproducible. I have applied it myself.

    However, this is not equal to, for example, “faith” in a god. The leap of faith that science is correct is a tiny one to make, since all the evidence shows that science works. If it turned out that it didn’t work thanks to some amazing piece of evidence, I would have to change my belief. Conversely, faith in god is a massive leap of faith, to the point where belief is unreansoable. There is no real evidence, and any contrary evidence would only serve to strengthen the faith.

    In summary, someone needs to invent a grading scale, with reasonable belief at one end, and faith at the other, as the definitions of “faith” and “belief” are not fixed :P

    - AS

  4. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0W7Jbc_Vhw is relevant here.

  5. hey, thank you for the great deal of explaination. I am doin MS in genetics and i need to face this fly everyday… ;) i am very thankful to u for posting your work and helping me out with my doubts…

    regards
    rupika


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.